Evacuations of hospitals and other healthcare facilities can be lengthy and complex events. A 1990 study examined the evacuation of 34 hospitals and 46 nursing homes (Vogt 1990). In the 34 hospital evacuations at facilities that ranged from 99 to 310 beds, the largest facility took 5 hours to evacuate 127 patients, whereas the smallest hospital took 2 hours to evacuate 27 patients. The most rapid evacuation involved the movement of 57 patients in 1.5 hours (Vogt 1990). In addition to results of nursing home evacuations, it was found that the time to evacuate was not related to the number of patients evacuating. The strongest predictors of evacuation time were the nature of the threat (weather versus nonweather events), the ratio of staff to patients, and whether the facility was in an urban area (Vogt 1991). A more recent study documents the evacuation of 575 patients from a hospital prior to a hurricane (Cocanour et al. 2002). In this case, completing the evacuation took almost 28 hours. Of the 575 patients, 169 were discharged and 406 were taken to 29 other facilities.
Both Vogt (1990) and McGlown (2001) examine factors influencing the evacuation process in healthcare facilities. Although Vogt focuses on the implementation of an evacuation at an organizational level whereas McGlown focuses on individual decision making, the two studies have similar findings. Processes are shaped by factors such as threat, risk, time, resources, infrastructure impediments, internal and external environment, organizational characteristics, social linkages, and social climate.
In terrorist events, both patients and workers in healthcare facilities are vulnerable groups. Patients are at risk because they lack the ability to protect themselves. Workers are at risk because of the nature of their roles as caregivers and because of the extra burden that an emergency creates. Despite such difficulties, responding to an emergency can be successful with careful planning, training, and exercising.
Shortly after 1:00 p.m. on Thursday, May 8, 1997, clouds of foul-smelling smoke began pouring from a herbicide and pesticide packaging plant in West Helena, Arkansas. The incident began when smoke was emitted from a 1,500-pound bulk container of azinphos-methyl, a commercial brand of parathion, which is a chemical with toxicity levels similar to sarin (Vogt and Sorensen 1999). An alert was sounded, employees were evacuated, and the West Helena fire department was called. As the smoky, malodorous cloud drifted away from the plant, authorities ordered residents in a two-mile area downwind of the plant to evacuate and those in the two- to three-mile zone downwind to shelter-in-place.
Phillips County Regional Medical Center was the one medical facility evacuated following the release. Located across the highway from the fields surrounding the industrial park, the complete service hospital, providing care for residents in a 50-mile radius, employs about 330 people and has 155 beds.
The evacuation of the medical center was facilitated by efforts taken six months earlier to update the hospital’s evacuation plan and reconfirm support agreements for relocation sites and supplies. When the plan was updated, the entire staff had also participated in a mock drill. At the time of the incident, the safety officer observed the buildings across the highway being evacuated and questioned officials on the possibility of also being evacuated. When the director of nursing gave the “code white” alert (the signal that an evacuation to an off-site facility would follow), an evacuation plan that was familiar to staff was in place and had been practiced, and staff were amply prepared to move patients.
All patients who could be discharged were sent home with a physician’s nurse. Another four or five patients (the most seriously ill) were transferred to a hospital about one-half hour away. Approximately 17 patients in the rehabilitation unit were transferred to a vacant wing of the Crestpark Nursing Home accompanied by hospital support staff. One maternity patient evacuated to the nearby Phillips Community College, where the hospital staff had evacuated and opened emergency room services.
The evacuation of patients began at 1:40 p.m., and all but three patients (two on ventilators and one being stabilized in the emergency room) were out 55 minutes later. The remaining three patients were evacuated 15 minutes later. As per the evacuation plan, a variety of vehicles transported patients—vans, school buses, ambulances, private cars, and mortuary services vehicles. As a precaution, National Guard personnel provided security at the evacuated hospital.
Until the hospital could be reopened, hospital personnel operated a triage area, an emergency room, and a laboratory at the recently completed fine arts building at the community college. The space provided by the college suited the hospital’s needs. In addition to the space, dressing rooms with showers and toilets were readily available. The college also has an emergency medical technician program and a school of nursing. One of the rooms used for training nurses was used to house maternity patients until stabilized, but no other patients were kept overnight. Ambulance operators rerouted patients to other medical facilities as needed. Staff maintained records using a notebook computer. The college also provided a separate extension phone line for hospital staff use.
Although monitors indicated no contamination in the facility, the state health department required a thorough cleanup of the hospital before patients could be admitted. This meant that all hard services had to be scrubbed and all soft materials (drapes, etc.) had to be removed. The health department also required that all filters in the building be replaced before the interior cleanup was started. Staff were unable to locate the filters because of the special design and the fact the company making them did not operate on weekends. Recognizing the urgency of having the regional hospital operational, state officials exerted pressure to convince the company to alter its policy to aid in the recovery from this incident. The filter company extended its hours and worked through the night, delivering the replacement filters to the hospital on the following Saturday. The hospital staff began cleaning on Sunday in shifts, starting with the rooms where filters were replaced. The emergency room was considered the highest priority and cleaned first. The hospital was reopened on May 13, six days after the initial evacuation.
Source: Vogt, B.M., and J.H.Sorensen. 1999. Description of Survey Data Regarding the Chemical Repackaging Plant Accident, West Helena, Arkansas. ORNL/TM-13722. Oak Ridge, TN: Oak Ridge National Laboratory.
